Article 8114

Title of the article



Karnishina Natalia Gennadievna, Doctor of historical sciences, professor, head of sub-department of state-law disciplinies, Penza State University (40 Krasnaya street, Penza, Russia), 

Index UDK



Background. The article analyzes the state of the judicial system of the Russian Empire at the end of 1850s. Imperfection of the judicial system in the middle of XIX century was so obvious that it was impossible to use considerable measures; cardinal reconstruction of all institutions should have been made.
Materials and methods. The research of the problem was carried out on the basis archival sources, publications, published statistical and court proceedings. Relying on the opinion of lead Russian lawyers of XIX century the author proves the necessity of new juridicial statutes that absolutely changed the court system of the Russian Empire.
Results. In the centre of attention of the author is investigation of the structure of Russia’s reformation. The author proved uneffectiveness of the court before reforms due to a large number of incompleted cases and judicial red tape. The investigation of the features of civil and criminal processes was carried out.
Conclusions. After the analysis of the level of education of judicial officials, their financial position the author made a conclusion that the presence of different judicial bodies, the absence of the system of judicial legislation, the connection between judicial and administrative functions, slow judicial investigation which were added by shortages of judicial corps led to the crisis of the court before the reforms. There was a necessity to make several system reforms. 

Key words

judicial reform, court before reform, judicial officials, district courts. 

Download PDF

1. Gessen I. V. Sudebnaya reforma [Judicial reform]. Saint Petersburg: Knigoizd-vo P.P.Gershunina,1905,237 p.
2. Efremova N. N. Sudoustroystvo v Rossii v XVIII – pervoy polovine XIX vekov: (Istorikopravovoe issledovanie) [Judicial system in Russia in XVIII – first half of XIX centuries: (Historical-legal research)]. Moscow: Nauka, 1993, 217 p.
3. Koni A. V. Ottsy i deti sudebnoy reformy. K pyatidesyatiletiyu Sudebnykh Ustavov [Fathers and sons of the judicial reforms. Commemorating 50 years of Judicial Statutes]. Saint Petersburg: Izdanie T-va I. D. Sytina, 1914, 412 p.
4. Materialy po sudebnoy reforme v Rossii 1864 g. B. m., b. g. [Materials on the judicial reform in Russia of 1864]. Vol. 9, 638 p.
5. Foynitskiy I. Ya. Kurs ugolovnogo sudoproizvodstva [Course of criminal judicial system]. Saint Petersburg: Tip. tovarishchestva «Obshchestvennaya pol'za», 1912, vol. 1, 423 p.
6. Ministerstvo yustitsii za 100 let (1802–1902). Istoricheskiy ocherk [Ministry of justice for 100 years (1802–1902). Historical essay]. Saint Petersburg: Senat. tip., 1902, p. 76.
7. Kolmakov N. M. Russkaya starina [Russian old times]. 1886, bk. 12, pp. 512–519.
8. Moryakova O. V. Sistema mestnogo upravleniya Rossii pri Nikolae I [System of local self-government in Russia under Nicholas I]. Moscow: Izd-vo MGU, 1998, 136 p.
9. Koni A. F. Sobr. soch. [Collected works]. Moscow: Yurid. lit., 1967, vol. 4, 389 p.
10. Pobedonostsev K. P. Golosa iz Rossii. London, 1859–1860 [Voices from Russia. London, 1859–1860]. Moscow, 1976, bk. VII–IX, iss. 3, pp. 61–76.
11. Dzhanshiev G. A. Epokha velikikh reform [Epoch of great changes]. Moscow: Tipolitografiya Tov-va I. N. Kushnereva, 1900, 496 p.
12. Sudebnye ustavy 20 noyabrya 1864 goda za 50 let [Judicial statutes of 20th November 1854 for 50 years]. Ed by V. F. Fenenov, E. N. Berendts, I. A. Blinov. Petrograd, 1914, 287 p.
13. Sudebno-statisticheskie svedeniya i soobrazheniya o vvedenii v deystvie sudebnykh ustavov 20 noyabrya 1864 goda (po Penzenskoy gubernii) [Judicial-statistical data and considerations on enacting new judicial statutes of 20th November 1864 (in Penza province)]. Saint Petersburg, 1866, part 2, 97 p.
14. Seredonin S. M. Istoricheskiy obzor deyatel'nosti Komiteta Ministrov. Chast'. 2. Komitet Ministrov v tsarstvovanie Imperatora Aleksandra Vtorogo (1855 g. Fevralya 19 – 1881 g. Marta 1) [Historical review of Ministers’ Committee’s activcity. Part 2. Ministers’ Committee during the reign of Alexander II (19 February 1855 – 1 March 1881)]. Saint Petersburg, 1902, 357 p.


Дата создания: 21.10.2014 08:38
Дата обновления: 21.10.2014 10:03